Monday, November 13, 2017

Rossetti’s Love Column

Three women sit in a room and idly chat about their love lives. One wears a mini skirt with a low-cut blouse and ruby-red lipstick. She places her heels on top of the table and speaks of the many men she has loved. Another dons golden hair that falls in soft waves against her rosy-pink cheeks and blue eyes. She speaks in a low voice and gushes about how much attention she receives from the opposite sex and her particular affection for one young man. The third wears faded layered garments with unkempt grey locks loosely fitted into a braid. She describes the life of an old woman knitting needles and still waiting for the right man to knock on her door. These three distinct women can all be found in society today. Though they are different in appearance and have divergent avenues of life, they have one quality in common: they are all hopelessly searching for love. In Christina Rossetti’s sonnet “A Triad,” Rossetti offers the audience three types of women who are pursuing love on misguided paths: a harlot, an object of beauty, and a spinster.
Rossetti uses society’s idea of a harlot to describe the disillusion associated with seeking fulfillment of love through promiscuity. Rossetti introduces the promiscuous woman as the “one with lips / Crimson, with cheeks and bosom in a glow, / Flushed to the yellow hair and finger-tips” (1-3). Though red lipstick holds a reigning position in the world of beauty today, during Rossetti’s era, lipstick was typically seen as a perverse method of seduction. However, most cultures today still consider cleavage-bearing shirts to be inappropriate and licentious attire. The meaning of Rossetti’s phrase “flushed to the yellow hair and finger-tips” seems unclear, but the idea of a “loose” woman suggests a person with unrestrained sexual desires, meaning her passion reaches every part of her body, even her hair and finger-tips. Later in the poem, Rossetti states, “One shamed herself in love” (9). This line connects to the promiscuous woman because she garners a negative impression from society and ignores her moral codes by attempting to find love in various outlets. Though the woman may believe love lies in this precarious mode of living, she never finds true love and ends up feeling lost and empty.
Rossetti capitalizes on the appearance of a beautiful woman to address the vain pursuit of beauty in place of love. In the poem, Rossetti writes, “And one there sang who soft and smooth as snow / Bloomed like a tinted hyacinth at a show” (4-5). A graceful singer has always been considered an emblem of beauty to the world. In addition, fairer complexions, similar to the color of snow, characterize delicate and attractive women. Rossetti also uses the brilliant colors of hyacinth flowers to further describe the woman’s alluring nature. Because the woman has such an appealing appearance, she most likely attracts a lot of male attention, so it should not be surprising to readers that out of the three women, the beautiful one seeks love through marriage. Rossetti states, “one temperately / Grew gross in soulless love, a sluggish wife” (9-10). Since the man only married the woman for her beauty, he neglects her when she grows old and unattractive. The woman dwells in soulless love because the man’s love for her was only skin deep and did not involve her heart.
Rossetti depicts the life of a loveless old maid to illustrate the negative effects of a life in sole pursuit of love. Rossetti says, “And one was blue with famine after love, / Who like a harpstring snapped rang harsh and low / The burden of what those were singing of” (6-8). The spinster may have had previous experiences with affection, but she never found true love. The phrase “blue with famine after love” suggests that she dwells in old age, dismal from the shortage of love in her life. Because of the old maid’s lack of love, her demeanor becomes bitter and aggrieved. Rossetti chooses to compare the resentful maid to a broken harpstring since the harpstring makes a “harsh and low” sound when it snaps, similar to the woman’s harsh outlook on love. Rossetti writes, “One famished died for love” (11). The woman famishes during the “famine” she experiences because of love’s absence. The old maid spent her entire life seeking love, wasting her limited days on earth and eventually died in vain before finding fulfillment.
Though Rossetti does not make it clear which one of the women “droned in sweetness like a fattened bee” (13) and which two “Took death for love and won him after strife” (12), the reader can decipher the possible meaning. The harlot could be the bee since she seeks love in many sources, filling herself with the sweet juices of deception dressed as affection like a bee growing fat from collecting pollen and nectar from countless flowers. The beautiful woman might have mistook the man’s love of her appearance for love of her soul and left life an unloved woman when her beauty faded. However, Rossetti does make it evident that the spinster died in hopeless search for love. Though all three women looked for love in different ways, Rossetti states that they were “All on the threshold, yet all short of life” (14). Because all three women tried to find love on misguided paths, they inevitably discovered themselves at death’s door before stumbling upon true love. Rossetti’s poem offers her readers harsh realities and applicable advice about love. Love cannot be discovered in sex or beauty, and a life should not be wasted in sole pursuit of love.

3 comments:

  1. Gracie, this was a very intriguing paper to read. You did an excellent job of comparing all three women with modern day women who love in the same way. It is so true that these types of love are seen prominitly. One adorns scandalous apparel, one has natural beauty, and one grows gray while waiting for any attention given to her. And yet, we cannot call this love because love is based off of more than a physical attraction. It makes one wonder why women feel the need to gain love in this way? All fall short because true love does not exist through these methods. I like how you said "love cannot be discovered in sex or beauty". I wish the world would embrace this way of thinking.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Congratulations Gracie! You figured this sonnet out! Your explanations of each type of woman makes more sense than the actual sonnet. The three types of women are very distinct once I read your paper. Each strove after love in an incorrect manner, and each suffered because of it. I agree with your point that the two women who died because of love were the natural beauty and the spinster. The fattened bee would then fall to the seductress or harlot. Overall, your thorough reflection and thought in this paper clears up any confusion that a reader might encounter with this sonnet.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Gracie, your paper lured me right in with your accurate descriptions of all the women. Reading this one time made it seem like you really do have it all figured out! Your descriptions of the women made sense regarding their physique and mannerisms. I also agree that Rossetti was trying to tell us all that you'll be knocking at death's door sooner rather than later if you invest all your time searching for love. In today's society, the idea is that falling in love is the only thing that will make us happy. I definitely agree, however, that overall message was not to obsess over unhealthy love. I really loved this paper!

    ReplyDelete